Reading Teruhisa Miike's "Let's Get Rid of School! (Let's Not Attend School)--The Minds of Children are Worn Out"
1) Yokohama National University
I. Introduction
This book, with its bold title "Let's Get Rid of School! (Let's Not
Attend School), says that the problem of school avoidance (The definition
used in Japan of "students that avoid school" is those that do
not attend school because of some psychological, emotional, physical or
societal cause or background and also those that are absent 30 or more
days per year because they cannot attend even if they want to, with the
exception of those with reasons such as sickness and economics. This is
a big problem in Japan, which has school education strongly controlled
by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology),
which has had various interpretations mainly as a psychological problem
up to this point, is actually juvenile chronic fatigue syndrome accompanying
learning and memory functional disorders, in addition to the three major
disorders that significantly reduce mental functions, such as central nervous
system functional disorders, hormonal secretion functional disorders and
immune functional disorders such that "the minds of children are worn
out" as the subtitle indicates.
The importance of this book is in the point of its distancing itself from the psychological approach that has not found any effective solutions for this and engaging the school avoidance problem in the new terms of the "brain," regardless of its being talked to death in recent years. Well then, concretely, just what kind of phenomenon is the school avoidance problem when viewed from the standpoint of the brain? The author directly states that the condition of school avoidance and juvenile chronic fatigue syndrome is a confusion of the functions of the brain controlling life forces and the higher order brain functions. This functional disorder comes from neural cell fatigue based on continuous anxiety and tension, and as a result, learning functions are obstructed, and a marked lowering of academic achievement occurs. If we get a new grasp on the rearing of children from the standpoint of fostering lively mental activity in them, this naturally has an intimate connection with the current state of society and the educational system. Therefore, this book first investigates the changes in the brains of children in recent years, next considers the environmental problems of home, school and society involved in this, and finally proposes concrete measures, that is something like a medical prescription, based on experience with children that have been in clinics. Focusing on the changes in the brains of children in particular, this article summarizes the content simply in the following.
II. Changes in the Brains of Children
(1) Characteristics of Brain Changes
If we take a look at the changes in the brain functions of children, we
can confirm a deep correlative relationship between them and the modern
school and societal systems. These can be summarizes as follows. There
are three points. First, video games and computers drive the development
of brain functions, and problems are solved immediately based on a large
quantity of knowledge. In other words, there is quiz-oriented "knowledge
accumulation and extension of problem solving capabilities centered on
the temporal lobes" and "speed in information processing functions
from the visual area to the cognitive area," and the results that
have arisen in the continued demand for being a "good child"
in the group oriented life at school are "the development of a self
inhibiting and cooperative brain." Conversely, four points are indicated
in the phenomenon of reduced brain function. First, because of the fatigue
and anxiety arising from constant tension resulting from the excessive
inhibition (autoinhibition) of amygdaloid bodies, which are intimately
related to one's own values, because of playing the part of a "good
child," it is noted that we see "underdeveloped frontal lobe
functions," inclusive of the prefrontal cortex, which is called "the
brain of the mind." This is tied to symptoms of passiveness and the
phenomenon of quickly losing control over agressive emotions. Second, "the
underdevelopment of the brain functions for spatial perception and stereognosis,"
third "functional atrophy of the autonomic nervous system and the
brain for the life force (the limbic system mainly centered on the hypothalamus),"
and finally "the absence of overall brain balance and the underdevelopment
of linguistic functions" that can be seen in poor vocabulary and linguistic
abilities are raised.
(2) Juvenile Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and School Avoidance
The major problem behind these changes in the brain and especially the lowering of brain function is "fatigue." If this were simple transient fatigue for which recovery is possible, it would be fine, but chronic fatigue knocks biological rhythms out of alignment, and everyday life is disrupted because of sleep disorders, making for a chronic jet lag like state. The result of this continuing over a long period of time is said to be juvenile chronic fatigue syndrome (state of school avoidance). In a word, it is not too much to say that this juvenile chronic fatigue syndrome throws the functions of the body into confusion. In the United States, chronic fatigue syndrome is called Chronic Fatigue Immune Disfunction Syndrome, and as demonstrated by the fact that calling it Neuroendocrine Immune Disorder (NEID) was examined at the Fifth International Chronic Fatigue Society Conference in 2001, it is a pathological condition in which functional abnormalities in the central nervous system, abnormalities in hormonal secretions and abnormalities in immune functions appear toghther. The more you read about the details of the conditions in which functional abnormalities in the central nervous system, abnormalities in hormonal secretions and abnormalities in immune functions appear together, the more you cannot but be alarmed by the importance of this occurence in the bodies of children that avoid school. In other words, it shows that the state of school avoidance is not only physical fatigue, but also fatigue in the brain. Typical Symptoms of School Avoidance: They cannot get up in the morning, and activity begins around noon, but no matter how much they sleep, they are always tired. Because of too much sleep, the rythm of everyday life is broken down, and there is a drop in mental activity as a whole, starting with will power and the power of concentration. Their heads are confused and concepts are not realized, and within this, they can suddenly become violent within the family. All of this can be explained through the relationship with juvenile chronic fatigue syndrome. For example, one serious problem largely related to the development of juvenile chronic fatigue syndrome is the malfunction of hypothalamic functions, particularly the body temperature regulation function. Because of this, the deep body temperature is maintained at a high level thought to be near the temperature of the brain. It does not drop even during sleep, and the brain is always overheated (there generally being a 1.5 degree gap between the deep body temperature during sleep at night and druing activity in the day, and there is a fluctuation of 1/f representing the life force of a person, but with chronic fatigue syndrome, there is no fluctuation, and the brain temperature does not drop during sleep). While the secretions of adrenal cortical hormone should be the highest up to 7:00 a.m., this slips three hours or more on average, and secretions are lowered by that amount. Furthermore, along with melatonin which lead to sleepiness, and beta-endorphins, both with, cortisol, which provide for morning activity, have lower secretions in the same manner, and slippage in the secretion times arises. Thus, juvenile chronic fatigue syndrome forms obstructions to the appropriate secretions of hormones and body temperature regulation necessary for carrying out everyday life, confuses the brain that maintains the life force and higher order brain functions, and results in the complication of obstructing learning functions as will be discussed next.
(3) Functional Disorders in Learning and Memory
I would like to introduce the
results of three tests with extremely deep significance for the functional
learning and memory disorders that accompany this juvenile chronic fatigue
syndrome.
One is the examination of cerebral blood flow using SPECT, Xe-CT, etc.,
and the results are that the flow of blood in the thalamus and frontal
lobe is poor with juvenile chronic fatigue syndrome, but there is an increase
in the blood flow in the basal ganglia. The reduction of blood flow in
the thalamus, which has the function of distributing the information collected
from the entire body and the frontal lobe, which governs concepts, creativity,
planning, sociality and ethics and further, has functions for adjusting
behavior, sensory integration and autonomic nerves, corroborates the symptoms
of new information having trouble getting in, reduction in cognition, poor
attentiveness, as well as learning and memory disorders. The authors view
the increase in the blood flow in the basal ganglia, that is in the amount
of information, as an increase in "anxiety information within the
brain," but this point is very interesting and probably requires further
examination in the future. As an even more shocking thing about blood flow
in the brain, results have come out in recent reports showing that there
is an overall reduction in cerebral blood flow in adults, and in particular,
a reduction in the blood flow in the 24 Broadman areas intimately related
to emotions, adjustments in the autonomic nerves and metabolic functions,
the important nine areas for communication responsible for working memory
and areas of the frontal lobe. This is not just limited to juvenile chronic
fatigue syndrome, and it can be thought to indicate that important changes
in the brain are progressing in our society as a whole.
Second, the results of investigations of the cognitive abilities of children
avoiding school teach u! s that the root of the problem is "a state
of continued stress." As a result of investigating the latent delay
of P300 brain waves (showing a drop in cognitive ability), school avoiding
children react to all stimuli in a supersensitive manner whether necessary
or not. In other words, their brains are always tense.
Third, accumulated choline is present in the frontal lobe, and this corroborates
the reduction in scholastic ability. Behind choline, which is a part of
the neurotransmitter acetylcholine, not being reused by the synapses, is
the fact that in a condition of continued sympathetic nerve tension, the
supply of acetyl CoA does not keep up with the choline and acetic acid
broken down from acetylcholine being consumed in large quantities. As a
result, there is a reduction in the production of acetylcholine, causing
a functional disorder in the choline operation nerve cells for learning
and memory, making study impossible. Looking at the above results, this
cannot be dismissed with just "they don't want to do it", and
we see a reality of the brain that cannot be dealt with solely by rote
memory learning.
III. The Atmosphere around Children and the
Brain
Behind the drop in brain function of children is the presence of a situation
in current families, schools and society that weakens the will to live
itself. If we look at the conditions necessary for a lively fostering of
their brains tracking the development of the human brain, the first is
emotional stability, and based on this, there is development of the limbic
system, which includes the hypothalamus and pituitary gland, followed by
the possibility of a forward development of the brain, from the occipital
lobe to the frontal lobe. However, if there is no loving care in the home
or a sense of security that confirms existence unconditionally, the self
is lost in the requirement for autoinhibiting cooperativeness at school,
and a target adult form cannot be found in society either. If there are
no desires or goals for the future, what will happen to children? In this
environment full of anxiety, confusion arises in the limbic system, which
can be called "brain of life" indispensable for supporting life.
The authors, who have seen a large number of cases of school avoidance,
have daringly proposed "getting rid of school," strongly criticizing
the current school system and assert that education from here on should
be carried out in an intimate relationship with the developmental physiology
of the brain. In addition, they raise ideas such as suitable medical responses
and making schools open places through regional cooperation and cooperation
with guardians for realistically handling school avoidance, and having
complete mental health care.
IV. Conclusion
Currently the number of children avoiding school at the elementary and
junior high school levels has reached 130,000, and this is said to exceed
2.5% of the total. The fact that this number of school avoiding children
has appeared and that it is currently increasing should make us recognize
that there is a problem with the school educational system itself and with
our societal system itself. This book analyzes the school avoidance problem
based on medical and physiological data concerned with the brains of children
and actual clinical cases, and it concludes that with the current school
system, it is necessary for children to "get rid of school" rather
than "return to school," as a specific medical remedy. Get rid
of school? That may have more significance for children suffering from
school avoidance in terms of obtaining various options when earnestly searching
for to secure a lively brain and way of life rather than for the current
behavior itself. Aside from the question of wanting to actually get away
from school, the ability to have a varied sense of values is at the very
least a force in escaping from the feeling of being cooped up. Finally,
I think the brightest side in this book that handles the school avoidance
problem from the viewpoint of the brain is that the problem is not the
children suffering from school avoidance themselves. By being able to talk
about the problems of the school avoidance specifically in terms of the
body( particularly brain), we can grasp our own vague situations more concretely
from an approach other than the psychological one and view the problem
objectively. I would like to have expectations for the results of this
brain research not only in terms of the school avoidance problem and educational
problems but also in terms of its becoming a foundation for deepening the
quality of life in the future based on the realities of children.
[Index]